Tuesday, 30 November 2010

Reflections on the Coaliton of Resistance Conference

So I am going to report back on the two workshops which I was involved with at the Coalition of Resistance Conference on Saturday. As I was also on the conferences organising committee, I was kept busy. Others have reported on the plenaries.

I chaired the session on ‘Political Representation’ and on the panel were Billy Bragg, our own Green councillor from Norwich Samir Jeraj, Liz Davies from the Haldane Socialist Lawyers Society who was speaking in a personal capacity and New Statesman and Guardian journalist Laurie Penny, who is also an activist.

Samir started by speaking about what was happening In Norwich. He is the Deputy Leader of the Green Group there and they almost took control of the council in September. He confirmed the determined resistance of Green councillors there to cuts and his view on how these cuts could be opposed by sitting councillors. This was later added to by former Labour leader of Lambeth Council in the 80s, Ted Knight, known as Red Ted, who argued that councillors should block cuts and if necessary force officers to try and run the council with occupations by council workers and others.

Laurie Penny who had been on the protests with the school students that week said that there had been a widespread feeling among those who marched that mainstream politics was dead. Laurie’s view was that there was a huge gulf between parliament and people. Laurie is a young person and her views reflected those of many students etc. She made the point that the chants on the march had changed from ‘no cuts to education’ to ‘no cuts to public services’. MPs, according to her, were divorced from reality and from people’s priorities. In the 80s there had been an illusion of an alternative politically but now there was none. For many young people the Lib Dems had been that alternative but now the Lib Dems were in a government using the police to kettle them. Laurie’s view was that there was a total political gap between young people and the political representatives. But she singled out Caroline Lucas as one MP who was different and that she had been on the police lines on the day of the kittling arguing with them to release the young demonstrators. This, according to Laurie, was what an MP should do to reconnect with the young.

Billy Bragg spoke initially about his involvement in the anti-BNP campaign in Barking and Dagenham and how they had crushed the BNP politically there. For him the statement issued by the Coalition of Resistance harked back to Old Labour. In Barking Labour had been consistently in power since 1931 and as New Labour under Blair had abandoned the working class, there had been a political void. This was indicated by the fact that local MP Margaret Hodge had not even had a constituency office there until the election of the BNP councillors. The BNP had filled that void. It was a pity, said Bragg, that all of the councillors elected in May had been from the Labour Party, which effectively created a one party council with no real opposition. He admitted that he had voted for the Lib Dems in May as the Labour Party only received 10% of the vote where he lived.

Bragg then went on to argue for AV, stating that this was the only way to change political representation and address some of the problems which Laurie had raised. He accepted that AV was not ideal but his view was that it was a staging post on the way to full PR and argued that this had happened in some other countries which introduced AV. This had also been part of his rationale for voting Lib Dem. He argued that it was quite possible that Labour could never win again on its own under the old system and that AV was vital.

Liz Davies, whom I had heard much of but had not yet met, gave a history of her political development from Labour Party NEC member to someone who had been active in the Socialist Alliance and other Left projects. Liz made a deep impression on me as a strategic and principled speaker. She asked what the alternatives were at the ballot box as she maintained that the anti-cuts movement must have some political representation at the end of the day. For her there were three possible alternatives. The first was the Labour Party, which provided no real alternative to the cuts agenda. She pointed out that other Social Democrat parties were presiding over cuts in Spain and elsewhere. Labour only offered the choice of voting for softer cuts which was no real choice at all.

The second choice was the Lib Dems who had completely destroyed their radical credentials and who when in local government often acted hypocritically. The third choice was the Green Party, which she had voted for and although she had great admiration for Caroline Lucas as an MP, the party had a mixed record in local government and needed to be integral to the anti-cuts movement.

Finally, there was the Left ,which had tried constantly to build unity but had failed utterly. For Liz the Left had been plagued by ‘quick fix’ solutions and attempts at name changing from one failed entity to another. Clearly she had Respect and Socialist Alliance in mind here. For her any real party to the Left of Labour needed to have trade unions on board and above all needed to be built on democratic principles.

She also demolished Billy Bragg’s arguments on AV, claiming that it was a shabby compromise not worth supporting and that real PR must be the goal – the AV solution would leave the UK stuck in a half way house which could turn out to be worse in the long run for stopping real democratic change. This was the view strongly supported by the many who attended the workshop.

The workshop unanimously passed a resolution to be taken back to COR calling for full resistance from all Local Authorities to cuts and full support for those councillors opposing them.

The workshop where I spoke was on ‘Why COR?’ Paul Mackney and Andrew Burgin, both members of the Steering Committee as I am, went into some detail about the history over the last few months. I decided to take the bull by the horns and I denounced the sectarian Left and argued that we needed to do radical politics in a very different form and that despite being a historian and understanding historical events such as the Kronstadt Revolt, the fall of Kerensky etc, that we were not living in 1917 or fighting the Russian Civil War and must move beyond old and staid ways of doing things and above all be non-sectarian. I also denounced the Irish Greens and made the point that many of us had been criticising them since they entered the disastrous coalition government.I qouted also from some of Liz Davies's comments in the earlier workshop. Many of those present who were Anarchists, from Climate Camp or from local anti-cuts groups applauded my comments on the sectarian Left and echoed them in their own contributions, stating that they had to overcome their initial distrust of COR to become involved.

It was interesting that Chris Bambery of the Right to Work Campaign (aka the SWP) was also at this workshop and gave a shorter version of the speech on Left unity which he later gave to the closing plenary. I think that the SWP and others can see that the overwhelming feeling of those at the conference was opposed to sectarianism of any kind. But with four members at least of the SWP now on the National Council along with a host of other organisations, including ten Greens (mostly from Green Left) we will see how this works out.

London Ambulance Service NHS Trust Board Meeting and Dr Foster Hospital Guide

I will be attending the Board meeting of the London Ambulance Service NHS Trust today, where the involvement of LAS in the 7/7 Inquest will be among issues discussed. It is also significant that hospital turnaround times have increased significantly in the last few months, i.e. the time that ambulances have to wait at A&E to hand over patients. Data and Board papers are available on the LAS website. As the Chair of the LAS Patients Forum, I put questions at the meeting and am often the only member of the public present.

NALM (National Association of LINks Members) has also forwarded the following information re the Dr Foster's Report on the state of various hospitals. Well worth checking out how your local hospital is faring.




It is 10 years since the first Dr Foster Hospital Guide was published. In some ways much has
changed in 10 years, but in other ways not enough has changed. A decade ago we had data
on all hospital admissions, from which we compared mortality ratios and other measures.
That data is still our main source of information. We have no primary and community
care data, no private sector data and no data that shows what happens to patients over
the whole course of their illness. Excitingly, the Coalition Government seems committed
to finally addressing this issue, and the 2010 guide is in part a case for more and better
information. More on this from Roger Taylor on page 6.

The Hospital Guide has also changed over the past 10 years, although some constants
remain. We continue to publish Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratios (HSMRs) but, in
addition to this, have now introduced two other ways of looking at mortality. You can find
the results on pages 16-17.
For the 2010 guide we have teamed up with leading clinicians and analysts to shine the
spotlight on three areas important to many patients: stroke, orthopaedics and urology
(see pages 18-25). And we have returned to the thorny subject of safety. The publicity
around last year’s safety index took some by surprise, but raised awareness of the risks
facing patients. This year we look back to see where there has been improvement and
where problems remain. The 2009 guide prompted some changes, including a Department
of Health task force on measuring mortality and new rules around the reporting of safety
incidents. However, we still have some way to go to get reliable data about ‘adverse events’.

We are also trying out some new ways of presenting information on our website. Visitors
to www.drfosterhealth.co.uk can now specify which aspects of patient experience matter
most to them and then find out which hospital trusts perform best on the relevant criteria.
As ever, thanks must go to all those who have helped make this year’s guide come to life,
especially the experts whose commentaries and opinions you will find throughout the
report. Thank you also to those individuals in each NHS trust who coordinated activity
around the Hospital Guide, not least in responding to our annual survey, to which 99 per
cent of trusts returned data.

The challenge we set ourselves is to produce a report which is accessible for patients and
the public and valid for clinicians and managers. This guide has been 10 years in the making and we hope you find it stimulating and informative.

Alex Kafetz, Dr Foster

Monday, 29 November 2010

Mark Thomas call to the unions and Coalition of Resistance Press Release

Spent yesterday recovering from the Coalition of Resistance conference on Saturday where I was chairing one workshop, speaking at another and also on the Conferences Arrangements Committee - so feeling pretty whacked afterwards.

Below Mark Thomas calls for unity between trade unionists and students. I believe that this is already happening today with students from UCL on the picket lines with the striking Underground workers.

And here is the press release issued today by the Coalition of Resistance.

Coalition of Resistance

Tel: 07939 242 229

Web: www.coalitionofresistance.org.uk

Email: coalitionofresistance@mail.com

CONTACT : David Wilson 07951 579 064

PRESS RELEASE 29 November 2010:


David Cameron will get his "big society" quicker than he thinks, judging by the huge attendance at a conference called last Saturday 27 November by the Coalition of Resistance to Cuts and Privatisation.

Over 1200 delegates packed the conference, which brought together MPs, trade unions, campaigning organisations from across the country, student activists, representatives from pensioner groups -- all corners of society facing government plans to cut public services to the bone.

Speakers at the conference -- from MP John McDonnell to Len McCluskey, the newly elected leader of Britain's largest trade union UNITE -- all had the same message, the spirit of which was captured by 15-year-old school Barnaby Raine, who joined last week's protests against education cuts:

"If the police think that 'kettling' students will stop us coming on demonstrations ever again, they are sorely mistaken. Students have only two choices: either they lay down and accept what the government throws at them, or they fight back."

The student protests and occupations are inspiring new levels of militancy and audacious action, which will be taken up across all the campaigns to stop the government cuts.

As MP John McDonnell told the conference, we will build a fast gathering, united movement of opposition, which will see strikes, demonstrations, occupations, direct action and campaigns of civil disobedience, on a scale not seen for a generation.

Tony Benn, who was elected president of the Coalition of Resistance, said David Cameron is going to see what a "big society" really looks like.

He spelled out the task we are facing: a government which aims to roll back 60 years of progress, and return to the dark days before the creation of the welfare state, must be stopped in its tracks.

The Coalition of Resistance will support all anti cuts campaigns and is calling for the widest solidarity with the national day of student protests on Tuesday 30 November. A national week of action against the cuts is planned for February 2011 and the Coalition of Resistance is committed to help make the TUC demonstration against the cuts on 26 March one of the biggest protests ever seen in Britain.


David Wilson 07951 579 064

Lindsey German 07810 540 584

Friday, 26 November 2010

Call out the cavalry! Evidence of police charge.

Evidence here of police violence against the demonstratiors on Wednesday, many of whom were school children. This was denied by the Met Police before  now but the evidence is there for all to see. The Guardian has also reported on the comments of those who were there to witness it.

Violence of protestors is condemned but state violence is condoned. The Met Police Commissioner is also ramping up the presssure claiming that we can expect more violent demos. Has the ConDem government decided to call out the cavalry as their predecessors called out the cavalry against the miners and the Yeomanry at Peterloo? So much for a government respecting civil liberties. There must be the strongest protest about this at the highest levels of London and national politics. I would hope that the Green London Assembly members will condemn it also any candidates who hope to stand for the Assembly in 2012.

Thursday, 25 November 2010

You have no shame! Irish politician lays into government minister

I am deeply angry and frustrated, as are many other Irish people, about what the morally bankrupt and now financially bankrupt Irish coalition government of Fianna Fail and Greens have done to my country. The result will be emigration and poverty and debt for the many of the poorest and most vulnerable in the country for years to come. Here on Irish television, the opposition TD, Pat Rabbitte, of the Irish Labour Party lays into a government minister and tells it like it is.

Wednesday, 24 November 2010

Coalition of Resistance Conference on Saturday

I will be speaking in the workshop on Why COR? and also chairing the session on elected representatives and the cuts, which will include a Green Party councillor from Norwich.
coalition of resistance logo

Coalition of Resistance Against Cuts & Privatisation

Newsletter 9
November 23

Come to Saturday's conference and plan the resistance to cuts

Director Ken Loach will speak at the conference

Coalition of Resistance National Conference

Saturday November 27

Camden Centre

Bidborough St, London WC1H 9AU


Conference Agenda


• Unemployed/Student Rate £3

• Standard Rate £5

• Representative £10

Register and pay for the conference Online

Conference Registration

[Unemployed / Student \/]


[ ]

Address - Email

[ ]0

Register and pay for the conference by cheque

Download and print off the registration form and send it to our office address below with a cheque made payable to 'Coalition of Resistance'

Coalition of Resistance

c/o Housmans Bookshop

5 Caledonian Road

London N1 9DX

As the crisis deepens and students begin the resistance, now is the time to come together to plan a mass united campaign against cuts and privatisation.

Already over 700 have registered for the conference of the Coalition of Resistance this Saturday in London. If you have not yet registered, it is not too late! Just go on-line and pay through our website.

Speakers at the conference include Tony Benn, Heather Wakefield UNISON, Lowkey, Jean Lambert MEP, Bob Crow RMT, Clare Solomon NUS, Christian Mahieux (Solidaires union, France), Dot Gibson (Pensioners campaigner), John McDonnell MP, Lindsey German CoR, Billy Bragg, Ken Loach and many others.

There will be workshops on topics like organising against the cuts, analysing the crisis and our response, the welfare state, and defending pensions and benefits. Everyone will have a chance to contribute with their experiences and ideas about how to resist, and help shape the campaign we all need.

The recent demonstration against the rise in fees by over 50,000 students and the occupation of the Tory party headquarters shows how to fight: mass demonstrations against those directly responsible for destroying our services and our welfare rights.

Last week, over 300 school students demonstrated in Finchley, North London, against Education Maintenance Grants being abolished and university fees rising to unaffordable levels.

This Monday students at SOAS are occupying their university, also in protest at the rise in fees and the swingeing cuts of up to 40% in teaching budgets.

On Wednesday, university and school students will again be demonstrating across the country against the proposed exorbitant fees which will destroy their hopes to access higher education.

In London, a Carnival of Resistance will set off at 11am from ULU, Malet Street for Trafalgar Square with performers like Mark Steel, Lowkey, and People's Army.

The emergency bail-out today of Irish banks shows that the crisis is not over. The current round of massive cuts and job losses was justified to repay the debt created by the bail-out of banks two years ago. But even deeper attacks may be on the way to fund yet another bank bail-out.

Every organisation and individual who supports the ideals of the welfare state created over 50 years ago must come together and join the resistance to defend heath, education and other services that are ours. We need to go to every street and workplace to argue that this crisis is not of our making, and that we will not pay for it.

Come to the conference this Saturday to plan together the resistance against cuts and privatisation, and to defend the welfare state.

Spread the word

As well as coming yourself, please spread the word as widely as possible:

• Forward this bulletin to all your contacts

• Join the facebook event and invite your friends


• Copy onto your profile and tag this photo with your friends. Get others to do the same!


• Cross-post this link on relevant facebook pages and conversations.


Stewards required

We need stewards for the conference - phone Sam on 07872 481769 if you'd like to help - free lunch and t-shirt for those who apply.

Unsubscribe fred.leplat@gmail.com from this list
Forward to a friend
Update your profile


Our mailing address is:

Coalition of Resistance

Coalition of Resistance, c/o Housman's Bookshop, 5 Caledonian Road

London, London N1 9DX

Add us to your address book

Copyright (C) 2010 Coalition of Resistance All rights reserved.

Monday, 22 November 2010

The political situation in Ireland reaches fever pitch

Latest news from Dublin tonight is that the Taoiseach (PM) Brian Cowen has acceeded to the demands of the Green Party, only issued today, that a general election be called in late January following the passing of Ireland's 4th, and most brutal, hairshirt budget next month. The Greens, who have supported this government for three years, have finally found their voice, but are still prepared to vote for a budget which includes measures like reducing the minimum wage.

But hang on, surely the proper way to do things is to hold a general election, and then have a government which has a democratic mandate, pass any budget? No, Cowen and Fianna Fail want to hang on to the bitter end, and bitter it will be judging by the latest opinion polls, where Fianna Fail are on 17%, a record low for the historically largest party. However, there are indications that the election will be sooner than January and I suspect that the government may not last beyond this week. Already there are indications that both the two Independents and some Fianna Fail backbenchers have no confidence in Cowen and will not support the budget. Ironic that the Greens will support the budget then. But the Greens are so deeply implicated in many of the worst decisions of the last few years that I feel their fate is sealed. No amount of spinning will save them now. The Irish people are angry and there will soon be a lot of trouble. Some indications of it are already apparent. And another question is how large will be the bill be

This government has been one of the worst in Irish history and that is saying something. I expect that in future historians will compare them with the 18th century placemen and corrupt office holders who voted the Irish parliament out of existence in 1800.

Wars and rumours of wars plus Ireland

I was away on the weekend before last in Belgium, visiting the historic city of Ghent for the first time. Our visit to Belgium coincided with an immense downpour and it rained all day on the Saturday. Belgian television was full of images of flooded towns and villages and of dykes bursting in Flanders. At one point the Eurostar line south of Brussels was closed. On returning via Brussels on the Monday, the headline in the Brussels version of the Metro newspaper was "Belgium under water" with aerial photos of deluged villages. This was a stark reminder once again of the impact of climate and weather.

On my return to London, I completed my course on independent brokerage and have now a certificate to prove it. Tuesday night saw me sharing a platform with my old sparring partner, Kate Hoey MP, at a public meeting on the Afghan war organised by Lambeth Stop the War Coalition. Leaving behind yah boo politics, I paid tribute to Kate's anti-war credentials, having been one of only 14 MPs to recently vote against the Afghan war, and she in turn paid tribute to the Green Party's long resistance to the interventionist wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Here is a picture from the evening. Naturally this was a build up to the Stop the War national march against the Afghan war on Saturday.

I spent Wednesday completing the minutes of the Green Left general meeting held about ten days before, only to be plunged back into more minute taking at the Green Left committee meeting on Thursday night. Being the Secretary is one of the most labour intensive jobs. At the meeting we discussed a number of issues including motions to the spring conference, where I am putting forward a motion, recently agreed at the Stop the War Coalition annual conference, on giving the power to declare war back to parliament and away from the Prime Minister, exercising the sovereign's prerogative.

On Saturday I was on the Stop the War Coalition march and carrying the Green Left banner in the march, as well as meeting up Greens from across the country who had come along to support it. I was disappointed that turnout was not higher - it was about 5,000 - and think that there is a need for the Coalition to reconsider strategy It is clear that the majority of the population are opposed to the war but it seems are not yet ready to march against it. Another photo from the demo below.

In the interim I have been following the news from Ireland closely. A text message from my brother in Dublinon Thursday summed up the views of many Irish people. It read: "the country is bolloxed. The IMF are in Dublin." The Irish Greens in government have a lot to answer for in their role over the last three years. As one of them told me in London 2 years ago: "we are in government with a kleptocracy." Yes indeed, and now the Irish people, at least those who will not be forced to emigrate, will pay the price for decades. My views on the role of the Irish government were summed up very well in the Observer editorial on Sunday.

Most of this week will be spent, when not working, preparing for the Coalition of Resistance conference on Saturday to ensure that the UK road to recovery is not the same as the Irish one.

Friday, 12 November 2010

Marches and protests change history

Lindsey German of Stop the War Coalition on the importance of protest and a similar view from Johann Hari. In the context of this week's student demo, did the anti-war protests fail? As someone who went on about 12 of them since the big one in 2003 and who is on the Steering Committee of Stop the War Coalition, I think that it is too early to say. To paraphrase Chou En Lai when he was asked if the French Revolution had been a success, "it is too early to know." The marches may not have stopped the war and at a time when the Afghan war continues relentlessly it appears that they were ineffective but on the other hand they have changed many minds and did huge damage to Blair and others. One of the reasons why I will be marching tomorrow week in the Time to Go march in London calling for withdrawal from Afghanistan.

Thursday, 11 November 2010

Afghanistan - Reasons to demonstrate

Remembrance Day and the costs of war

Today is Remembrance Day, the day on which World War I, the war to end all wars, ended. Yet the UK is still involved in a war in Afghanistan which has now lasted longer than both world wars combined. The body count this year, both among NATO troops and Afghan civilians, was the highest yet in this war and continues to rise. The war continues to cost millons, while today Ian Duncan Smith announces futher savage cuts to welfare and benefits which will penalise both unwaged and disabled people. Yet there is still plenty of money flowing to the war in Afghanistan.- despite the fact that the vast majority of the population are opposed to this war.

Listening to Radio 4's Today programme this morning I heard an interview with ex-servicemen, many of whom have ended up unemployed and homeless - the very people who will be on the sharp end of Duncan Smith's 'reforms'. Next Tuesday I will be addressing a public meeting on the war in Lambeth organised by Lambeth Stop the War Coalition, also on the platform will be my former opponent from the general election camapaign in Vauxhall, Kate Hoey, who, to give her credit, has been one of only a handful of MPs to vote against the war recently - Caroline Lucas being one of the others.

And mentioning World War I reminds me of the brilliant war poetry of that era of doomed youth. Here for Remembrance Day is a war poem for our generation.

To mark Remembrance Day, we reproduce this traditional song/poem, written and first performed way back in November 2009.

There's rats in the trenches
A thousand foul stenches
Of piss, pus and puke, blood and death
Jim's screaming his head off
'Cause Frank hasn't got one
And Joey's just drawn his last breath
While back home in Surrey
They try not to worry
And keep all their doubts locked inside
For in a few years
There'll be no more tears
And they'll all wear their poppies with pride...

She can't understand
As she holds the girl's hand
That her daughter's no longer attached
They were all blown to hell
As a terrorist cell
Though a wedding was all that they'd hatched
And back in the West
They're so sure they know best
Though they've tortured and murdered and lied
And they don't want to know
What the body counts show
As they all wear their poppies with pride...
Oh, they all wear their poppies with pride...

At the annual board meeting
Arms dealers are greeting
Reports of their profits with glee
They'll always be willing
To make a quick killing
From slaughter and mass misery
And when it's all over
They'll head off to stuff
The big bellies their suits cannot hide
And they won't spare a thought
For the carnage they've brought
But they'll all wear their poppies with pride...
Yes they'll all wear their poppies with pride...

Whoever you mix with
There's bound to be someone
Whose mind is still caught in the mesh
Those soldiers aren't heroes
They're nothing but fodder
For the thing that grows fat on our flesh
And you show no respect
For the ones left behind
Or the miserable sods who have died
If you can't face the truth about why they were killed
And you still wear your poppies with pride...
If you still wear your poppies with pride....
Do you still wear your poppies with pride?

(Paul Cudenec, 2009)

Wednesday, 10 November 2010

Public schools and Teachers Pension Scheme

 Have been extremely busy over the weekend and the last few days, attending the Green Left general meeting on Saturday and taking the minutes, and am also back this week on the independent brokerage course. So I did not get time to link to the article below which appeared in the Guardian on Saturday, where London Green Party Chair, Noel Lynch, is quoted. I am also preparing for a tribunal taking place tonight in my local party, Lambeth, regarding a complaint I am bringing about another member's conduct and had to spend half of Monday writing out my statement. In the interim, there has been more grim news from Ireland, with predictions that the economy there is heading for bankruptcy - falls in the Euro yesterday suggested major concerns with the Portugese and Irish economies.

Link to the article in  Guardian newspaper:


[3] Analysis of the FOI response by the London Federation of Green Parties:

The response names all the public schools that are admitted the Teachers' Pension Scheme.

Admittance to this scheme is important because employers participating in this scheme are only charged 14.1%(1) of pay for providing these final salary benefits. However this low employer contribution is only possible because of factors such as (a) the government's strong credit rating and (b) Treasury assumptions underpinning the calculation of the contribution rate. Schools would not be allowed by the Pension Regulator to make similarly optimistic assumptions if they ran their own pension scheme. Independent analysis suggests that the "true" contribution rate should be 10% higher to reflect these factors (2). While the Green party would not accept this analysis fully (because it is a partisan attempt to make public sector pensions seem unaffordable) it is certainly the case that, as private institutions, schools such as Eton and Harrow would have to contribute at least 20% of pay for the same benefits provided by the Teachers' Pension Scheme.

The value of this subsidy is considerable.

The 11 named institutions in the FOI response (including the schools attended by the Prime Minister, Chancellor, Deputy Prime Minister and Energy Secretary) have 1,639 members of staff in the scheme (Eton, for example, has about 150 full time teaching staff - information from its website). At an average subsidy of 6% of pay and assuming average pay in these institutions of £45,000 (a rather conservative assumption) then the subsidy to just these 11 institutions every year is almost £4.5 million (£400,000+ per annum for an institution like Eton). The top 100 schools are looking at over £40 million in subsidy per annum (a FOI could back that up if necessary).

On top of this, the risk and expense of running a pension scheme of this nature has been taken out of the hands of these institutions. Similar sized organisations are having great difficulty managing the investment risk associated with such schemes as stock markets fluctuate. These schools are given an exemption from these risks by the government for free. Likewise the schools don’t have to go to the expense of funding trustee bodies to run the schemes or appointing actuaries or lawyers to advise on them. Similarly there is no pension protection fund levy where otherwise there would be one.

These factors greatly increase the hidden subsidy.

Finally being able to offer the same pension provision that the state offers makes it easier for these schools to attract top performing staff from the state sector.

(1) see: http://www.teacherspensions.co.uk/employers/employers13.htm

(2) see: http://www.public-sector-pensions-commission.org.uk/wp-content/themes/pspc/images/Public-Sector-Pensions-Commission-Report.pdf (page 8)


Friday, 5 November 2010

Ireland in ferment while government is forced to call by elections

As the largest student demo in decades snaked its way through Dublin, calling for the scrapping of the doublin of fees and some students occupied the Dept of Finance but were also attacked by police, the coalition government braces itself for another austerity budget. However, the government's fate now hangs by a thread. With a wafer thin majority, a Fianna Fail backbencher recently resigned from the Dail (the Irish parliament) stating that his heart was no longer in the government's programme and that a general election was necessary.

This is the decaying Fianna Fail and Green coalition's greatest fear and the reason why scandalously they have refused to move the writ on 4 by elections which need to be called for the Dail. One constituency, Donegal North West, has had no representative since the summer of 2009. An opposition senator took the government to court and now the High Court has ruled that the government's actions are contrary to the Irish constitution. The government's reaction was to suggest challenging the ruling in the Supreme Court. But reason prevailed and the writ has been moved for November 25th. This will mean that the new TD (MP) will take their seat before the vote on the austerity budget. The other by elections will be held early next year. We are witnessing the dying days of a discredited and morally bankrupt government, many of whose members created the crisis in the first place and who have steered Ireland down the road to bankruptcy and mass emigration while their friends, the corrupt developers and bankers who created all of this in the first place, continue to live off the fat of the land. Their days are numbered. And ironic that this is the government and the economic plan on which Osborne and his crew have modelled their cuts and growth agenda.

The impact of roadworks in the capital on ambulance services - a public meeting of the London Ambulance Service Patients Forum on Monday night at City Hall

The Ambulance Service is meeting at City Hall on Monday night to discuss how roadworks and utilities works in the capital are impacting on ambulance services. The situation has become really bad. One basic example is when the tunnels under the Thames are blocked or closed for repairs or traffic jams, resulting in massive gridlock. This is a real issue for emergency medical services in London and the Chair of the Transport Committee is being invited to speak along with a London Ambulance Service Manager. We will also be discussing the community responders project and the report back from the national ambulance design project.


Monday November 8th 2010


‘Roadworks, Utilities works and Ambulance Delays’ – Val Shawcross (Chair of GLA Transport Committee) Nick Yard (Ambulance Operations Manager LAS Tower Hamlets)

Monday November 8th 2010


Committee Room 2, City Hall, The Queens Walk, SE1

Forum’s Officers:

CHAIR: Dr Joseph Healy j-j@freezone.co.uk or PatientsForumLAS@aol.com

VICE CHAIR: Sister Josephine Udie Sisterjossi@hotmail.com

VICE CHAIR: Lynn Strother director.glf@pop3.poptel.org.uk

VICE CHAIR: Malcolm Alexander PatientsForumLAS@aol.com

BSL signers will be available

Boris should sack Coleman

Comment below on Brian Coleman or as the FBU term him "Toad of City Hall."

Boris Johnson should sack Brian Coleman says London Green Party Chair

Noel Lynch, Chair of the London Green party, has called on Boris Johnson to sack Brian Coleman, the chair of the London Fire Authority, and either appoint someone capable of resolving the escalating dispute with the FBU or take charge of negotiations himself.

Lynch commented:

"The Mayor has to intervene to find a solution to this situation. The risk Londoners are being exposed to is unacceptable. Brian Coleman does not have the trust of ordinary firefighters and has not handled negotiations with the FBU appropriately. Saying that firefighters are 'easily replaceable' and accepting the hospitality of strike-breaking firm AssetCo has made a bad situation worse. The issue is far too serious to be allowed to drift along in the manner it has done to date. Boris Johnson has to step in and appoint someone capable of reaching an acceptable deal with the FBU or take charge of negotiations himself."

Monday, 1 November 2010

Ireland - backdrops and paintballing

Meanwhile across the Irish Sea in the Irish Republic, from where thousands of young people are emigrating in the face of the economic crisis, the madness of capitalism shows itself again. The ghost estates - thousands of developments left empty after the construction boom and then the economy collapsed, are going to be used as backdrops for drama series and for paintball games for the corporate executives who remain. It rather reminds me of the famous Potemkin villages of imperial Russia.

As Louis XV is reputed to have said, after having been warned that a revolution would follow in France during the reign of his grandson: "Apres mois la deluge." Which translates as something akin to - "once I have gone all hell will break loose." Which indeed turned out to be the case. I also think this would make a suitable epithet for the former Irish PM (Taoiseach) Bertie Ahern, who has left the country facing ruin and bankruptcy.

An Irish friend of mine who wanted to return to Ireland but who is disabled and on benefits asked about getting a place to live there and was told by Dublin Corporation that there was a ten year waiting list for social housing. I asked the official what about all of the empty properties around the country? Well, she said, they are not suitable because there are no transport links and they will probably be bulldozed anyway. Jonathan Swift, if he had been alive, would have been moved to write another satirical tale about the gombeen republic and its corrupt politicans and bankers.

London FBU strike today

The Green Party Trade Union Group sent the following statement to the London Firebrigades Union regarding the industrial action today and on November 5th and 6th. I will be going to join the picket line at Lambeth Fire Station on Albert Embankment later today. Here is also a report from the Politics Show on the issues involved and refusal of London's Tories, in the person of Brian Coleman, to deal with the dispute.

I am sending you the support of the Green Party Trade Union Group who decided at our committee meeting to totally support the London fire strike and the struggle of the FBU against the draconian measures being introduced by the London Fire and Emergency Planning Authority and the threat of sackings. We stand
in solidarity with you and hope that your industrial action will bring the employers to the table for further negotiations and that they will end their attempts to settle this dispute under duress.

Members of the Green Party and Green Party Trade Union Group will be joining picket lines across London on November 1st and on the 5th and 6th of November.

In Solidarity

Joseph Healy


Green Party Trade Union Group